Shop by Department
We buy surplus in bulk. Click here to get a free valuation.
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor
Sponsor Sign InBecome a Sponsor

Buffalo (1913-38) | Surplus Network

1 Buffalo Nickel Indian Head 5 Cent 1913-1938 Random Date US Mint [Circulated]
USA
1 Buffalo Nickel Indian Head 5 Cent...

$1.49 USD

1 Buffalo Nickel Indian Head 5 Cent...

$1.49 USD

1913-1938 Buffalo Nickels 20-Coin Roll (Full Dates)
USA
1913-1938 Buffalo Nickels 20-Coin...

$26.73 USD

1913-1938 Buffalo Nickels 20-Coin...

$26.73 USD

BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel lot (3) Coins with FULL DATES - Native American Lot!
USA
BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel lot (3)...

$5.75 USD

BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel lot (3)...

$5.75 USD

Lot of Indian Head Penny, Liberty V and Buffalo Nickel, Steel & 2 Wheat Pennies
USA
Lot of Indian Head Penny, Liberty V...

$7.49 USD

Lot of Indian Head Penny, Liberty V...

$7.49 USD

Half Roll of 20 FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels!
USA
Half Roll of 20 FULL DATE Buffalo...

$18.95 USD

Half Roll of 20 FULL DATE Buffalo...

$18.95 USD

Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel Coins Partial Dates - All Different Years!
USA
Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel...

$4.79 USD

Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel...

$4.79 USD

Ten 10 FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels!
USA
Ten 10 FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels!

$9.95 USD

Ten 10 FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels!

$9.95 USD

1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - AU - About Uncirculated
USA
1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - AU -...

$11.99 USD

1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - AU -...

$11.99 USD

US COINS- Silver WW2 Nickel, Liberty Nickel, Buffalo Nickel- 3 Coin Set- NO JUNK
USA
US COINS- Silver WW2 Nickel, Liberty...

$8.95 USD

US COINS- Silver WW2 Nickel, Liberty...

$8.95 USD

1935 Buffalo Nickel - Almost Uncirculated (AU)
USA
1935 Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$15.95 USD

1935 Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$15.95 USD

1930
USA
1930's BLACK RUTHENIUM / 24K GOLD...

$15.95 USD

1930's BLACK RUTHENIUM / 24K GOLD...

$15.95 USD

1937-D Buffalo Nickel - Almost Uncirculated (AU)
USA
1937-D Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$15.95 USD

1937-D Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$15.95 USD

[Lot of 40] Buffalo Nickels Full Readable Dates - Choose How Many Lots of 40!
USA
[Lot of 40] Buffalo Nickels Full...

$39.95 USD

[Lot of 40] Buffalo Nickels Full...

$39.95 USD

1937+1937-D+1937-S Buffalo Nickel Set - Almost Uncirculated (AU) - 3 Coin Lot
USA
1937+1937-D+1937-S Buffalo Nickel Set...

$39.95 USD

1937+1937-D+1937-S Buffalo Nickel Set...

$39.95 USD

ESTATE LOT (200 Coins) NO DATE Buffalo Nickels.
USA
ESTATE LOT (200 Coins) NO DATE...

$48.01 USD

ESTATE LOT (200 Coins) NO DATE...

$48.01 USD

WHOLESALE LOT Roll (40 Coins) FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels. Nice Selection!
USA
WHOLESALE LOT Roll (40 Coins) FULL...

$32.95 USD

WHOLESALE LOT Roll (40 Coins) FULL...

$32.95 USD

VINTAGE Coin Lot of 20 Buffalo Nickels 1913-1938 Dateless FREE SHIPPING
USA
VINTAGE Coin Lot of 20 Buffalo...

$13.88 USD

VINTAGE Coin Lot of 20 Buffalo...

$13.88 USD

Starter Collection Lot of 6 US Coins, UNCIRCULATED, SILVER, & 100+ YEAR OLD
USA
Starter Collection Lot of 6 US Coins,...

$10.95 USD

Starter Collection Lot of 6 US Coins,...

$10.95 USD

Liberty Head V-Nickel 5 Cents Circulated Fine Full Date - 1 Coin Random Year
USA
Liberty Head V-Nickel 5 Cents...

$2.10 USD

Liberty Head V-Nickel 5 Cents...

$2.10 USD

1928 D Buffalo Nickel Free Shipping SHARP AU / BU
USA
1928 D Buffalo Nickel Free Shipping...

$58.00 USD

1928 D Buffalo Nickel Free Shipping...

$58.00 USD

1937 P INDIAN HEAD "BUFFALO" NICKEL AVE CIRCULATED **FREE SHIPPING**
USA
1937 P INDIAN HEAD "BUFFALO" NICKEL...

$1.61 USD

1937 P INDIAN HEAD "BUFFALO" NICKEL...

$1.61 USD

Circulated 40 Coin Roll Full Date Buffalo Nickels
USA
Circulated 40 Coin Roll Full Date...

$34.00 USD

Circulated 40 Coin Roll Full Date...

$34.00 USD

1938-D Buffalo Nickel - Almost Uncirculated (AU)
USA
1938-D Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$16.95 USD

1938-D Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$16.95 USD

1937-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST FREE SHIPPING with tracking
USA
1937-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST...

$5.69 USD

1937-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST...

$5.69 USD

VINTAGE COIN Buffalo Nickels Lot of 6 DIFFERENT FULL DATE COINS 1926-1937 #B26
USA
VINTAGE COIN Buffalo Nickels Lot of 6...

$20.42 USD

VINTAGE COIN Buffalo Nickels Lot of 6...

$20.42 USD

24kt Gold Buffalo Nickel Lot of 10 Genuine Indian Head Coins SAME DAY SHIPPING
USA
24kt Gold Buffalo Nickel Lot of 10...

$10.00 USD

24kt Gold Buffalo Nickel Lot of 10...

$10.00 USD

Vintage Coin Lot of 10 Full Date, Fine Circulated Buffalo Nickels 1913-1938
USA
Vintage Coin Lot of 10 Full Date,...

$9.98 USD

Vintage Coin Lot of 10 Full Date,...

$9.98 USD

1 Buffalo Nickel Type Coin Sale One Vintage Old Coin per Order "Raw & Original"
USA
1 Buffalo Nickel Type Coin Sale One...

$1.69 USD

1 Buffalo Nickel Type Coin Sale One...

$1.69 USD

Huge Collection Of 100 Good-Very Good G-VG Buffalo Nickels 1913-1938 Estate Lot
USA
Huge Collection Of 100 Good-Very Good...

$84.89 USD

Huge Collection Of 100 Good-Very Good...

$84.89 USD

Vintage 1937 Buffalo Nickle-XF Grade-Full Dates!
USA
Vintage 1937 Buffalo Nickle-XF...

$3.99 USD

Vintage 1937 Buffalo Nickle-XF...

$3.99 USD

1924-S Buffalo Nickel G / VG  FREE SHIPPING
USA
1924-S Buffalo Nickel G / VG  FREE...

$20.00 USD

1924-S Buffalo Nickel G / VG  FREE...

$20.00 USD

ALL 12 NICE Coins 1934 - 1938 P D S BUFFALO NICKELS 5c! Starter Set! FREE P/H
USA
ALL 12 NICE Coins 1934 - 1938 P D S...

$21.59 USD

ALL 12 NICE Coins 1934 - 1938 P D S...

$21.59 USD

1 OZ Buffalo Nickel Round .999 Pure Copper Bullion BU
USA
1 OZ Buffalo Nickel Round .999 Pure...

$5.09 USD

1 OZ Buffalo Nickel Round .999 Pure...

$5.09 USD

1934 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG
USA
1934 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$2.45 USD

1934 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$2.45 USD

1937 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG
USA
1937 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$2.45 USD

1937 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$2.45 USD

1938-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST FREE SHIPPING with tracking
USA
1938-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST...

$9.49 USD

1938-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST...

$9.49 USD

BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL LOT (3) COINS WITH FULL DATES ALL DIFFERENT DATES
USA
BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL LOT (3)...

$4.95 USD

BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL LOT (3)...

$4.95 USD

Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel Coins Partial Dates FAST FREE SHIPPING
USA
Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel...

$4.95 USD

Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel...

$4.95 USD

1936 Buffalo Nickel - Almost Uncirculated (AU)
USA
1936 Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$12.95 USD

1936 Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$12.95 USD

BUFFALO NICKELS FULL DATE 9 PER LOT
USA
BUFFALO NICKELS FULL DATE 9 PER LOT

$11.95 USD

BUFFALO NICKELS FULL DATE 9 PER LOT

$11.95 USD

buffalo nickels lot
USA
buffalo nickels lot

$17.00 USD

buffalo nickels lot

$17.00 USD

GOLD BUFFALO NICKEL - Pure 24K GOLD PLATED Buffalo Indian Head Nickel (2-PACK)
USA
GOLD BUFFALO NICKEL - Pure 24K GOLD...

$6.95 USD

GOLD BUFFALO NICKEL - Pure 24K GOLD...

$6.95 USD

Old US Coin Estate Lot Silver War, Buffalo, & Liberty V Nickels 3 Coin Set
USA
Old US Coin Estate Lot Silver War,...

$6.95 USD

Old US Coin Estate Lot Silver War,...

$6.95 USD

1914 P Buffalo Nickel | Slick Condition | *acid restoration*
USA
1914 P Buffalo Nickel | Slick...

$3.00 USD

1914 P Buffalo Nickel | Slick...

$3.00 USD

1927 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG
USA
1927 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$2.55 USD

1927 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$2.55 USD

Indian Head Penny, Buffalo Nickel, Steel Wheat Cent, and Two Wheat Pennies Lot
USA
Indian Head Penny, Buffalo Nickel,...

$5.95 USD

Indian Head Penny, Buffalo Nickel,...

$5.95 USD

Liberty V Nickel, Buffalo Nickel, Steel Penny, Wheat Pennies Lot FREE SHIPPING
USA
Liberty V Nickel, Buffalo Nickel,...

$5.95 USD

Liberty V Nickel, Buffalo Nickel,...

$5.95 USD

1918 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG
USA
1918 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$6.25 USD

1918 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$6.25 USD

1921 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG
USA
1921 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$6.25 USD

1921 P - Buffalo Nickel - G/VG

$6.25 USD

1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - VF - Very Fine
USA
1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - VF - Very...

$4.99 USD

1938 D Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - VF - Very...

$4.99 USD

🔥🔥 Blowout Buffalo Circulated Nickel Deal!! Both Full Dates And Partial Dates
USA
🔥🔥 Blowout Buffalo Circulated...

$1.00 USD

🔥🔥 Blowout Buffalo Circulated...

$1.00 USD

Buffalo Nickels Assorted Lot of 40
USA
Buffalo Nickels Assorted Lot of 40

$40.00 USD

Buffalo Nickels Assorted Lot of 40

$40.00 USD

1926-S Buffalo Nickel Low Grade Complete Your Album!
USA
1926-S Buffalo Nickel Low Grade...

$18.00 USD

1926-S Buffalo Nickel Low Grade...

$18.00 USD

Buffalo Nickels (2) Coins.. Each Lot Is .99 Shipping. All Readable Dates
USA
Buffalo Nickels (2) Coins.. Each Lot...

$2.00 USD

Buffalo Nickels (2) Coins.. Each Lot...

$2.00 USD

1917 5C Buffalo Nickel
USA
1917 5C Buffalo Nickel

$2.00 USD

1917 5C Buffalo Nickel

$2.00 USD

Buffalo Nickel Mixed Years Roll - Average (AG-Btr) (40 Coins)
USA
Buffalo Nickel Mixed Years Roll -...

$19.00 USD

Buffalo Nickel Mixed Years Roll -...

$19.00 USD

Estate Sale ~ Buffalo Nickels Lot of 40 DATELESS Coins ~ Buffalo Nickels Roll
USA
Estate Sale ~ Buffalo Nickels Lot of...

$19.24 USD

Estate Sale ~ Buffalo Nickels Lot of...

$19.24 USD

1927-D Buffalo Nickel G / VG FREE SHIPPING
USA
1927-D Buffalo Nickel G / VG FREE...

$11.77 USD

1927-D Buffalo Nickel G / VG FREE...

$11.77 USD

1914 S Restored Date Buffalo Nickel - Free Shipping- A220
USA
1914 S Restored Date Buffalo Nickel...

$5.99 USD

1914 S Restored Date Buffalo Nickel...

$5.99 USD

Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel Coins Partial Dates - All Different Years!
USA
Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel...

$5.99 USD

Lot of (5) BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel...

$5.99 USD

1913-1938 24K Gold Plate Rare Old US No-Date Buffalo Nickel Collection Coin USA
USA
1913-1938 24K Gold Plate Rare Old US...

$5.99 USD

1913-1938 24K Gold Plate Rare Old US...

$5.99 USD

Estate Lot ~ VINTAGE Buffalo Nickels Lot of 40 Partial Date Indian Head Nickels
USA
Estate Lot ~ VINTAGE Buffalo Nickels...

$26.59 USD

Estate Lot ~ VINTAGE Buffalo Nickels...

$26.59 USD

Estate Lot ~ Buffalo Nickels Lot of 40 CULL / DATELESS Old HEAVILY WORN Coins
USA
Estate Lot ~ Buffalo Nickels Lot of...

$17.66 USD

Estate Lot ~ Buffalo Nickels Lot of...

$17.66 USD

🔥ONE SHOTGUN ROLL 40 BUFFALO NICKEL FIVE CENT PIECES OLD COIN LOT! 1913-1938 🔥
USA
🔥ONE SHOTGUN ROLL 40 BUFFALO...

$57.85 USD

🔥ONE SHOTGUN ROLL 40 BUFFALO...

$57.85 USD

1917-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS F12 | Nice Remaining Details on this Semi-Key Date
USA
1917-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS F12 | Nice...

$99.99 USD

1917-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS F12 | Nice...

$99.99 USD

Lot of 25 FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels Free Shipping Take a Look
USA
Lot of 25 FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels...

$22.99 USD

Lot of 25 FULL DATE Buffalo Nickels...

$22.99 USD

1936-S Buffalo Nickel - Almost Uncirculated (AU)
USA
1936-S Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$17.95 USD

1936-S Buffalo Nickel - Almost...

$17.95 USD

1924-S Buffalo Nickel better date
USA
1924-S Buffalo Nickel better date

$7.77 USD

1924-S Buffalo Nickel better date

$7.77 USD

NIC-A-DATE
USA
NIC-A-DATE

$9.99 USD

NIC-A-DATE

$9.99 USD

1916 (P) Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - VF - Very Fine
USA
1916 (P) Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - VF -...

$9.99 USD

1916 (P) Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - VF -...

$9.99 USD

(1) 1913-D Denver T. 2 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel Acid Restored Key Date US 5C Coin
USA
(1) 1913-D Denver T. 2 Type 2 Buffalo...

$9.99 USD

(1) 1913-D Denver T. 2 Type 2 Buffalo...

$9.99 USD

1913 Buffalo Nickel Raised Mound Type 1 Free Shipping
USA
1913 Buffalo Nickel Raised Mound Type...

$1.99 USD

1913 Buffalo Nickel Raised Mound Type...

$1.99 USD

1935 (P) Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - AU -About Uncirculated
USA
1935 (P) Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - AU...

$12.99 USD

1935 (P) Buffalo Nickel 5¢ - AU...

$12.99 USD

1930-S Buffalo Nickel Full Date F-XF FAST FREE SHIPPING W/ TRACKING
USA
1930-S Buffalo Nickel Full Date F-XF...

$7.59 USD

1930-S Buffalo Nickel Full Date F-XF...

$7.59 USD

Buffalo Nickel Mixed Years Roll - Good - Better (40 Coins)
USA
Buffalo Nickel Mixed Years Roll -...

$25.00 USD

Buffalo Nickel Mixed Years Roll -...

$25.00 USD

1915-D Buffalo Nickel CHOICE AAU E211 QLM
USA
1915-D Buffalo Nickel CHOICE AAU E211...

$110.67 USD

1915-D Buffalo Nickel CHOICE AAU E211...

$110.67 USD

1920 Buffalo Nickel
USA
1920 Buffalo Nickel

$1.50 USD

1920 Buffalo Nickel

$1.50 USD

1928 buffalo nickel
USA
1928 buffalo nickel

$0.99 USD

1928 buffalo nickel

$0.99 USD

1936-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST FREE SHIPPING with tracking
USA
1936-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST...

$6.64 USD

1936-D Buffalo Nickel Full Date FAST...

$6.64 USD

1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 62
USA
1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 62

$120.00 USD

1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 62

$120.00 USD

ESTATE LOT (100 Coins) PARTIAL DATE Buffalo Nickels. Nice Selection!
USA
ESTATE LOT (100 Coins) PARTIAL DATE...

$37.21 USD

ESTATE LOT (100 Coins) PARTIAL DATE...

$37.21 USD

1916 P Buffalo Nickel | Slick Condition | *acid restoration*
USA
1916 P Buffalo Nickel | Slick...

$2.50 USD

1916 P Buffalo Nickel | Slick...

$2.50 USD

1918-D Buffalo Nickel CHOICE VF E157 ANL
USA
1918-D Buffalo Nickel CHOICE VF E157 ANL

$85.67 USD

1918-D Buffalo Nickel CHOICE VF E157 ANL

$85.67 USD

1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC AU 58
USA
1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC AU 58

$75.00 USD

1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC AU 58

$75.00 USD

Lot of 10 Full Date BUFFALO NICKELS US Coins Gold Plated Indian Head -Best Value
USA
Lot of 10 Full Date BUFFALO NICKELS...

$34.95 USD

Lot of 10 Full Date BUFFALO NICKELS...

$34.95 USD

BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel lot (3) Coins with FULL DATES - All Different dates!
USA
BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel lot (3)...

$6.10 USD

BUFFALO Indian Head Nickel lot (3)...

$6.10 USD

1926 P Philadelphia Mint Buffalo Nickel G/VG
USA
1926 P Philadelphia Mint Buffalo...

$3.79 USD

1926 P Philadelphia Mint Buffalo...

$3.79 USD

1935-D Buffalo Nickel Partial Date FAST FREE SHIPPING
USA
1935-D Buffalo Nickel Partial Date...

$3.79 USD

1935-D Buffalo Nickel Partial Date...

$3.79 USD

Collection Mix Lot of 3 RARE US Coins NO LONGER FOUND IN POCKET CHANGE
USA
Collection Mix Lot of 3 RARE US...

$7.50 USD

Collection Mix Lot of 3 RARE US...

$7.50 USD

(100) US Buffalo Nickels Full Date Pre-1938 Nice Lot No Culls
USA
(100) US Buffalo Nickels Full Date...

$59.99 USD

(100) US Buffalo Nickels Full Date...

$59.99 USD

1937-S Buffalo Nickel G / VG  FREE SHIPPING
USA
1937-S Buffalo Nickel G / VG  FREE...

$6.94 USD

1937-S Buffalo Nickel G / VG  FREE...

$6.94 USD

Lot of 10 partial date buffalo nickels, 5C 1913 to 1938 circulated coins
USA
Lot of 10 partial date buffalo...

$7.98 USD

Lot of 10 partial date buffalo...

$7.98 USD

Old US Coin Estate Lot Buffalo Nickel Steel Cent Mercury Dime 3 Coin Set
USA
Old US Coin Estate Lot Buffalo Nickel...

$6.99 USD

Old US Coin Estate Lot Buffalo Nickel...

$6.99 USD

Group Lot of 10 Slabbed U.S. Buffalo Nickels
USA
Group Lot of 10 Slabbed U.S. Buffalo...

$23.50 USD

Group Lot of 10 Slabbed U.S. Buffalo...

$23.50 USD

1935 Buffalo Nickel — AU+ Toned 🌈
USA
1935 Buffalo Nickel — AU+ Toned 🌈

$14.00 USD

1935 Buffalo Nickel — AU+ Toned 🌈

$14.00 USD

1919-D Buffalo Nickel G / VG FREE SHIPPING
USA
1919-D Buffalo Nickel G / VG FREE...

$37.99 USD

1919-D Buffalo Nickel G / VG FREE...

$37.99 USD

1921 Buffalo Nickel CHOICE XF E164 KM
USA
1921 Buffalo Nickel CHOICE XF E164 KM

$46.57 USD

1921 Buffalo Nickel CHOICE XF E164 KM

$46.57 USD

[Lot of 40] Buffalo Nickels No Date / Low Grade - Choose How Many Lots of 40!
USA
[Lot of 40] Buffalo Nickels No Date /...

$19.95 USD

[Lot of 40] Buffalo Nickels No Date /...

$19.95 USD

BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL LOT (3) COINS WITH FULL DATES ALL DIFFERENT DATES
USA
BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL LOT (3)...

$4.85 USD

BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL LOT (3)...

$4.85 USD

1938-D/D 5C Buffalo Nickel Five Cent PCGS GRADED MS65 (BT408)
USA
1938-D/D 5C Buffalo Nickel Five Cent...

$79.45 USD

1938-D/D 5C Buffalo Nickel Five Cent...

$79.45 USD